Page 57 - Spring2013
P. 57

All Thumbs Book Reviews






          An Epidemic of Absence:                   in fact, even symbiotic, what he calls “mutual-
          A New Way of Understanding                ists.” They need us and we need them. The result
          Allergies and Autoimmune Diseases         is a delicate balance for the immune system in
          By Moises Velasquez-Manoff                which force to control the invaders must not
          Scribner 2012                             become so much force as to destroy the self. He
                                                    even claims that “parasites more than any other
              Moises Velasquez-Manoff is a science  factor (diet, climate) have influenced our evolu-
          writer who has taken on the job of translating an  tion” (page 94). In short, we are their creatures,
          ambitious scope of research for the non-medical  not the other way around!
          reader. The central thesis is that we humans     The island of Sardinia stands as an example
          evolved alongside parasites, mostly insects and  of what can happen when a perennial health
          worms, and that without their stimulus our im-  problem  is  eradicated.  After  World  War  II,
          mune systems get restless and look for targets  mosquito-bearing malaria was vanquished and
          which often end up being some part of ourselves.  the fairly homogenous population of indigenous
          This sort of “friendly fire” expresses itself as  Sardinians began to develop both multiple sclero-
          allergies, asthma and autoimmune diseases.   sis and type-1 diabetes at an alarming rate. Is the
              It’s important to point out that the many  explanation, as proposed here, that “gene vari-
          examples in the book are based on correla-  ants that helped defend against [malaria]….also
          tion, not causality. The correlations are indeed  increase the chances of developing autoimmune
          compelling, however. One, for instance, is that  disease” (page 46)? The logic is that people with
          mothers who live on farms with animals have  the genes to deal with malaria lived long enough
          children with fewer cases of asthma and aller-  to reproduce. They didn’t get MS or diabetes
          gies. Another correlation links the eradication of  because their immune systems were busy deal-
          malaria in Sardinia to a rapid rise in two auto-  ing with malaria. Without the mosquitoes those
          immune diseases: multiple sclerosis and type-1  fierce genes turned against the self. It almost
          diabetes. An Epidemic of Absence is dense with  sounds like a Hollywood horror movie to read
          such examples.                            the examples from around the world. The human
              This is a book built on the premise that  whipworm Trichuris trichiura also seems to
          such  immune-mediated  disorders  “arise  in  protect us humans from MS almost everywhere
          direct proportion to affluence and Westerniza-  on the planet.                       It is a delicate
          tion” (page 8). We no longer live in the kind of     We’ve seen in the Sardinian example that
          environment that we—including our immune  malaria seems to have discouraged MS and   balance for
          systems—evolved to expect. And that leads to  type-1 diabetes, afflictions in which the immune   the immune
          problems: allergies, asthma, autism and autoim-  system attacks, respectively, the myelin sheath   system in
          mune diseases like lupus, rheumatoid arthritis,  around nerves or the insulin-producing cells in
          and nearly a hundred others. Why is this? The  the pancreas. Malaria in parts of Africa seems   which force
          author, a sufferer from both allergy and alopecia  also to have discouraged rheumatoid arthritis,   to control
          (his immune system attacked his hair follicles  which affects joints, and lupus, which can affect   invaders must
          when he was a boy and he has been bald ever  organs, joints or nerves, as well as sickle-cell
          since), has carried out an extensive search for  anemia. Apparently, type-1 diabetics, lupus pa-  not become
          the answer and believes that “. . . much of our  tients and those with celiac disease all fare quite   so much force
          immune system evolved precisely to manage the  well with malaria. A small group of MS patients   as to destroy
          problem of parasites” (page 23). That being so,  in Italy who took the BCG (bacillus Calmette-
          those parasites aren’t really dispensable and are,  Guerin) vaccine for tuberculosis found their   the self.
 Wise Traditions   SPRING 2013  SPRING 2013          Wise Traditions                                           57
   52   53   54   55   56   57   58   59   60   61   62